Discuss this article at FlyTyingForum.com

Matching Feathers
by Ronn Lucas

Matching feathers sounds like a simple task. I thought it was at first but was I wrong.  I had tied flies with hackle tip wings and would take one, two or however many I was using for one side from one side of a skin and the others from the other side. I knew that this would result in a wing that stayed together well but those were just fishing flies.

Before I started to tie the fully dressed flies, I collected feathers and after awhile, started to pair feathers for future use as wings, sides or veilings. I happily plucked a feather from here and one from there and as long as they had the same size and shape, they were a pair (or so I thought.) This went on for several years. I had literally many hundreds of pairs of feathers from common to exotic all nicely put in zip loc bags.  I thought I was pretty smart for all of this work I did as I pawed through countless thousands of molted feathers from Peafowl to Parrots.

Well, the day finally came when I decided to actually start to tie fully dressed flies. When I started dipping into my hard won pairs, it didn’t take long to realize that I had made some serious errors in my pairing routine.  

When you want to tie two feathers back to back either as veils or wings, every curve and the location of the shaft and overall shape must be exactly the same or very nearly so.  A correctly matched pair of feathers will collapse to a perfectly straight line as viewed on edge (see photos). All feathers are extremely strong and their shapes are part of their strength. A straight curve will push in a more or less straight line where a compound curve which is mostly the case, will tend to corkscrew.  If one feather of a pair is a little smaller or has a slightly different curve, the stronger of the two when placed back to back and held there, will push the weaker one out of the way. Even if you can get two dissimilar feathers to flatten out back to back seemingly in harmony, a slight movement of one will disrupt the harmony and the pair/wing will “blow up”.  This can also happen with veils. You must remember the strength of the feathers and the fact that they are being held by a very tiny bit of thread on a very small section of the shafts. All of that tension is trying to exert leverage on the tie in point and “hinging” can take place very easily. For this reason, a very tight tie in is essential to wing stability.

Matched pair of feathers  Feathers back to back  Pair of feathers collapsed

For some reason which I am not sure of, exact matching pairs of feathers will cancel each other’s strength and almost lay flat against each other with very little effort compared to dissimilar feathers. 

When you are matching feathers from a skin, finding pairs is relatively easy compared to molted feathers. On a skin, feathers going straight down the center of the back and breast will be fairly straight compared to feathers further away. Those few center feathers will tend to have straight curves while the rest will be compound curves.

Matching from molted feathers is far more difficult and time consuming.  Remember that only feathers from the exact opposite spots on a bird will match exactly. Now, consider that a bird has maybe thousands of feathers and if there is more than one bird represented in the molted feathers, this number grows drastically. I have literally many pounds of molted parrot feathers from various kinds of birds and numbers of them. Out of say a pound of medium size body feathers; there might be a few dozen pairs IF they are from one bird. And add that every bird is a little different and you can see the amount of work that can be involved with pairing feathers. This is the reason that one needs literally thousands of feathers to get a fairly good number of pairs.

Matching feathers for sides and shoulders is a bit different. Here you have a little more leeway. The wing will support two sides that are a little different so exact pairs aren’t critical. BEST but not critical. 

I bet I have spent several thousand hours just pairing feathers over the years. I used to kinda like it but not so much now, depending on the kind of feathers.  Bottom line, it is tedious work but necessary in order to tie flies that look good and hold together.  I still have many large and small bags of unsorted feathers that taunt me every time I open a cabinet or box.

This is the important part of this article. My test for a matched pair of feathers. It is an easy, yet critical several steps. First, I match pairs that have the overall same size and shape (outside shape, curves and location of their shafts), hold them together, back (concave sides) to back, hold them up to a bright light to see if their shafts line up and finally, I flick them sharply with my finger. If they stay together and don’t move, they are a pair. I will then put a dab of hot glue to their bottom ends and put them along with similar pairs in a zip loc bag.  Feathers of the same size and colours are sorted together in boxes. I can go to any box and look for the colour feathers I want in a matter of seconds. I have thousands of pairs already to go. This saves a lot of time when I am tying a fly. If I can’t find paired feathers that will work, I will go through my skins and sort and match more. This way, the number of pairs grows.  Also, when my “mind is right” I will just spend a few hours and match feathers particularly when I have new skins or molted feathers I haven’t had before.

I hope you understand that every facet of what we do as tyers of fully dressed flies is important. If we slack off on any one, the quality of your flies will show it be it with lack luster feathers, lumpy floss, crooked ribs or rough heads.  You will know it and those who look at your flies will too. Still, as I always stress, tie to the best of your ability and have fun with it. It’s just a hobby and hobbies oughtn’t be work.

Happy Trails!
Ronn


Medium & large pairs


Small pairs

Tying Tips, featured »

[4 Aug 2010 | 5 Comments | ]
Tying Tips: Streamside Fly Tying Vise

This week’s typing tip is in response to a question by Hatches reader, Nick S. from Boise, ID. Nick wanted to know if we had any suggestions for a small, lightweight fly tying vise to use streamside, or on backcountry fly-in/ hike-in fly fishing trips.

Book Reviews & Excerpts, featured »

[2 Aug 2010 | 2 Comments | ]
Book Review: Trout Stream Insects by Dick Pobst

GLOBE PEQUOT ( THE LYONS PRESS, FALCON), November 1997
Binding Type: Hardcover
Retail Price: $16.95 at the Hatches Store
ISBN: 1-55821-067-9
“The trout’s biggest advantage is selectivity, and we can counteract it only by knowing the insects that make up his diet.  This is the reason for the study of stream entomology by the angler, and it is often the weak link in his skill.”
-Ernest Schwiebert
Trout Stream Insects: An Orvis Streamside Guide is by no means a new book.  However, since it was first published in 1990, it has successfully been introducing novice …

Product Spotlight, featured »

[26 Jul 2010 | No Comment | ]
Product Spotlight: Petitjean TT Bobbin

Called the “bobbin of bobbins,” Marc Petitjean’s “Thread Through Bobbin,” aims to solve a few classic design limitations of standard bobbins.

Articles, featured »

[21 Jul 2010 | No Comment | ]
Spring Olives by Russ Forney

Sand Creek is a pretty little piece of trout water that harbors some very fussy fish. Clear water in a small creek demands a quiet approach; casting from the bank is a good strategy when fishing small flies to springtime trout. Photo by Russ Forney
Springtime in Wyoming can be pretty elusive. Just when the first flush of prairie wildflowers sweetens the air, the next storm buries them under a foot of snow. Somewhere between the first Meadowlark and the last new calf, winter finally begins to relax its icy grip. …

Tying Tips, Videos, featured »

[16 Jul 2010 | 3 Comments | ]
Tying Tips: Working with Rubber Legs

With rubber legs showing up in more and more fly patterns, one common problem fly tier’s are facing is that they get in the way when tying a whip finish knot. In this week’s Tying Tips, Hatches Magazine staff member Alex Cerveniak shares three quick and easy ways to keep those rubber legs out of the way.



Hatches is an annual publication with a strong devotion to professional writing, beautiful photography and informative articles pertaining to both the artistic and practical aspects of fly tying. Each issue features 13 featured articles that span a massive 96 pages.

Fall 2010

Price: $6.95
Click Here
For More Info

Fall 2009

Price: $6.95
Click Here
For More Info

Fall 2008

Price: $6.95
Click Here
For More Info

Fall 2007

Sold Out. No longer available
Price: $6.95

What Our Readers Are Saying

I agree with the feedback you have received about Hatches. This is by far the best magazine I have seen that shares the wealth of knowledge without the additional 30 pages of vendor advertisements. I understand they are needed revenue but it is refreshing to see the quality of your articles etc. without having to thumb through all of the ads. I also take three other periodicals that are OK but no where nearly as good as Hatches. I wish you continued success and would like the opportunity to have 3 year subscriptions some time. Thanks again for all of your hard work and excellent presentation in Hatches. Best of luck, I wish you a long life and can\'t wait until you are recognized as the number one periodical presenting fly fishing knowledge.

I received my issue of Hatches this weekend and I have not been able to put it down. I have subscribed to many fly fishing and fly tying mags before. Yours is the first that I have seen that I can get some use out of. Nearly every article is something that pertains to me and I need all the help I can get. I don\'t know how you can keep this up but I will be watching for my next issue. Thank for all the hard work the staff has done. Very well done. Thank you.