Adult Mayfly Identification
Text: Roger Rohrbeck
Photos: Jason Neuswanger
For those unfamiliar with genus names, a common name for each genus is provided at the end of this article.
After a bit, we’ll walk through the identification of a mayfly, but first we need to set the stage by exploring some physical features of the winged stages of mayflies.
Is it a dun or spinner?
Mayflies are unique in the insect world, in that they have more than one winged lifestage, the dun (sub-adult or subimago), and the spinner (adult or imago).
Under most circumstances, the (dun or spinner) determination is easy to make.
A mayfly dun (subimago) has wings that are dull and opaque.
A mayfly spinner (imago) has wings that are hyaline (shiny and transparent).
Is it male or female?
Three easily observable features can be used to determine sex in the winged stages of mayflies:
- Eyes of male tend to dominate the head; eyes of female don’t.
- Fore legs of male are extremely long; fore legs of female aren’t.
- Male has forceps (claspers) to hold female during copulation; female doesn’t.
While all three of these features will not necessarily be observable, usually one or two are, and can be used to determine the sex of a winged mayfly.
How long is it?
The body of a mayfly is measured from the front of the head to the end of the abdomen, excluding tails. This measurement varies greatly from one type of mayfly to another. It ranges (from 2 mm.) for the smallest species (to 40 mm.) for the largest species.
These are the body length ranges (excluding tails) for most N. American mayfly genera:
Acentrella (4-6 mm.), Ameletus (9-14 mm.), Anthopotamus (7-18 mm.), Asioplax (3-6 mm.), Attenella (6-8 mm.), Baetis (4-10 mm.), Baetisca (10-14 mm.), Brachycercus (3-6 mm.), Caenis (2-4 mm.), Callibaetis (5-10 mm.), Caudatella (8-11 mm.), Centroptilum (5-7 mm.), Cinygma (8-10 mm.), Cinygmula (6-10 mm.) Diphetor (5-7 mm.), Drunella (6-16 mm.), Epeorus (7-14 mm.), Ephemera (10-30 mm.), Ephemerella (5-12 mm.), Ephoron (9-14 mm.), Heptagenia (8-14 mm.), Heterocloeon (5-6 mm.), Hexagenia (16-40 mm.), Ironodes (11-14 mm.), Isonychia (10-21 mm.), Leptophlebia (8-14 mm.), Leucrocuta (5-8 mm.), Litobrancha (15-40 mm.), Maccaffertium (7-16mm.), Metretopus (10 mm.), Nixe (8-11mm.), Paraleptophlebia (6-11 mm.), Plauditus (3-6 mm.), Procloeon (3-9 mm.), Pseudocloeon (4-6 mm.), Rhithrogena (7-11mm.), Serratella (4-9 mm.), Siphlonurus (9-16 mm.), Siphloplecton (13-19 mm.), Stenacron (8-12 mm.), Stenonema (9-11 mm.), Timpanoga (14-16 mm.), Tricorythodes (3-7mm.)
Are wings plain, or are they marked or mottled?
Some mayflies have wings that are plain (uniform in color), and others have wings that are marked or mottled (contrasting in color).
Among mayflies with plain fore wings are the following genera:
Acentrella, Ameletus, Anthopotamus, Asioplax, Attenella, Baetis, Baetisca, Brachycercus, Caenis, Caudatella, Centroptilum, Cinygma, Cinygmula, Diphetor, Drunella, Epeorus, Ephemerella, Ephoron, Heterocloeon, Hexagenia, Ironodes, Isonychia, Leptophlebia, Metretopus, Paraleptophlebia, Plauditus, Procloeon, Pseudocloeon, Serratella, Siphlonurus, Timpanoga, and Tricorythodes.
Marked or mottled wing
Among mayflies with marked or mottled fore wings are the following genera:
Callibaetis, Ephemera, Heptagenia, Leucrocuta, Litobrancha, Maccaffertium, Nixe, Rhithrogena, Siphloplecton, Stenacron, and Stenonema.
What size are the hind wings?
All adult mayflies have fore wings, and most adult mayflies also have hind wings. Whether the hind wings are obvious, minute, or absent is a key to identification.
Obvious hind wing
Among those mayflies with obvious hind wings are the following genera:
Ameletus, Anthopotamus, Attenella, Baetisca, Caudatella, Cinygma, Cinygmula, Drunella, Epeorus, Ephemera, Ephemerella, Ephoron, Heptagenia, Hexagenia, Ironodes, Isonychia, Leptophlebia, Leucrocuta, Litobrancha, Maccaffertium, Metretopus, Nixe, Paraleptophlebia, Rhithrogena, Serratella, Siphlonurus, Siphloplecton, Stenacron, Stenonema, and Timpanoga.
Minute hind wing
Among those mayflies with minute hind wings are the following genera:
Acentrella, Baetis, Callibaetis, Centroptilum, Diphetor, and Heterocloeon.
Absent hind wing
Among the mayflies with absent (no) hind wings are the following genera:
Asioplax, Brachycercus, Caenis, Plauditus, Procloeon, Pseudocloeon, and Tricorythodes.
Does it have 2 or 3 tails?
Winged mayflies have either two or three tails. Don’t confuse this with the number of tails the nymph has, as it may be different. Some mayflies have three tails as a nymph, but only two in the winged stages.
2-tailed Families (Genera)
Baetidae (Acentrella, Baetis, Callibaetis, Centroptilum, Diphetor, Heterocloeon, Plauditus, Procloeon, Pseudocloeon)
Ephemeridae (Hexagenia, Litobrancha)
Heptageniidae (Cinygma, Cinygmula, Epeorus, Heptagenia, Ironodes, Leucrocuta, Maccaffertium, Nixe, Rhithrogena, Stenacron, Stenonema)
Metretopodidae (Metretopus, Siphloplecton)
Polymitarcyidae (Ephoron male)
3-tailed Families (Genera)
Caenidae (Brachycercus, Caenis)
Ephemerellidae (Attenella, Caudatella, Drunella, Ephemerella, Serratella, Timpanoga)
Leptohyphidae (Asioplax, Tricorythodes)
Leptophlebiidae (Leptophlebia, Paraleptophlebia)
Polymitarcyidae (Ephoron female)
First, let’s "Observe"
Okay, now that we’ve explored some physical attributes of the winged stages of mayflies, let’s put your new observation skills to use. We’ll assume you’ve just parked your vehicle, and are in the process of putting on your waders. At this very moment, a mayfly lands on the back of your hand. You gently lift your arm, and make some observations before the mayfly discovers its mistake, and flies off.
- It looks to be 9 mm. (~3/8”) in length, about hook size #14.
- The eyes dominate the head.
- The fore legs are extremely long.
- You aren’t sure whether or not it has claspers.
- The fore wings are dark in color and marked with broad white veins.
- The hind wings are minute (luckily, you’re blessed with 20/10 eyesight).
- It has two tails.
Then, some "analysis"
Your new friend didn’t have hyaline wings, so it must be a dun. Its eyes dominated the head, and it had extremely long fore legs, so it must be a male.
By consulting the number of tails lists (see above), we can eliminate all but the following genera, which have a length range including 9 mm.
Acentrella, Ameletus, Baetis, Callibaetis, Centroptilum, Cinygma, Cinygmula, Diphetor, Epeorus, Ephemerella, Ephoron (male), Heptagenia, Heterocloeon, Ironodes, Isonychia, Leucrocuta, Litobrancha, Maccaffertium, Metretopus, Nixe, Plauditus, Procloeon, Pseudocloeon, Rhithrogena, Siphlonurus, Siphloplecton, Stenacron, and Stenonema.
By consulting the body length range list, we are able to eliminate all from the above list except:
Ameletus, Baetis, Callibaetis, Cinygma, Cinygmula, Epeorus, Ephoron (male), Heptagenia, Maccaffertium, Nixe, Procloeon, Rhithrogena, Siphlonurus, Stenacron, and Stenonema.
By consulting the fore wings lists, we are able to eliminate all from the above list except:
Callibaetis, Heptagenia, Maccaffertium, Nixe, Rhithrogena, Stenacron, and Stenonema.
By consulting the hind wings lists, we are able to eliminate all from the above list except:
So, as a result of this observation and analysis, you astutely conclude that your new friend must have been a Callibaetis male dun, commonly called a Specklewing.
Too much work?
My goodness (you say), this analysis is way too much work. Do I really have to do all that just to identify a winged mayfly I don’t already recognize? For the answer, see paragraph below.
Author and photographer
Roger Rohrbeck, an entomology enthusiast from the state of Washington, provided the text for this article. The above labor-intensive analysis is automatically performed by the Identification page on his website, http://www.flyfishingentomology.com/. One need only enter their observations, and click the Lookup button.
Jason Neuswanger generously authorized use of his insect photos for this article. In most cases, the photos have been cropped, annotated, or otherwise altered for illustration purposes. Jason’s vast gallery of aquatic insect photos can be viewed on his highly acclaimed website, http://www.troutnut.com/.
Common names for generaAcentrella (Minute Graywinged Brown), Ameletus (Brown Dun), Anthopotamus (Golden Drake), Asioplax (Tiny Whitewinged Olive Quill), Attenella (Golden Drake), Baetis (Bluewinged Olive), Baetisca (Specklewinged Dun), Caenis (Whitewinged Sulphur), Callibaetis (Specklewing), Caudatella (no common name), Centroptilum (Pale Watery Dun), Cinygma (Western Light Cahill), Cinygmula (Dark Red Quill), Diphetor (Iron Blue Quill), Drunella (Green Drake), Epeorus (Slate Brown Dun), Ephemera (Brown Drake), Ephemerella (Pale Morning Dun), Ephoron (White Drake), Heptagenia (Pale Evening Dun), Heterocloeon (Bluewinged Olive), Hexagenia (Hex), Ironodes (Slate Maroon Drake), Isonychia (Leadwing), Leptophlebia (Black Quill), Leucrocuta (Pale Evening Dun), Litobrancha (Dark Green Drake), Maccaffertium (Light Cahill), Metretopus (no common name), Nixe (Western Ginger Quill), Paraleptophlebia (Mahogany Dun), Plauditus (Bluewinged Olive), Procloeon (Bluewinged Olive), Pseudocloeon (Bluewinged Olive), Rhithrogena (Western March Brown), Serratella (Little Dark Hendrickson), Siphlonurus (Gray Drake), Siphloplecton (Speckled Olive), Stenacron (Cahill), Stenonema (Gray Fox), Timpanoga (Great Bluewinged Red Quill), Tricorythodes (Trico).
I am happy to announce that I just received a large shipments of hooks in this week. Just in time to help finish up filling your fly boxes before opening day! Click Here for More Info
Matt Grobert and Tightlines Productions team up on a very detailed video on how to tie a red quill. There are some great detailed tips around the winging and the quill body.
A winter themed Hatches Theater with Headhunters fly shop, Scientific Angler, and steelhead
Learn from OPST guide Trevor Covich how to tie a large intruder for big steelhead and king salmon.
GreenCaddis has just launched a new double sided waterproof fly box called the “FlyPad”. Store over 750 flies in one box. Click Here for more Info
I forget where I first learned it, but during a Trico hatch, all you need to do to catch the trout that are snubbing your trico pattern is tie on an ant. Over the last 10 years, Iâ€™ve found that ants are a trump card that no trout can refuse. This is especially true when […]
This is a great little, “do anything”, baitfish pattern. Color options are endless, limited only by the available colors of fox. This fly sinks very slowly, and can be worked just under the surface of the water, making it deadly for shallow water predators… Bass, Reds, Snook, baby tarpon… she will do it all.
Matt Grobert shows how to tie a Blue Winged Olive Quill Nymph. Video by Tightlines Productions
A look into Winter, Ed’s trips, and an obsession for Brown Trout…. Check out these 3 great videos
In the summer of 2013, the boys from Adipose Fly Fishing ventured north to a part of Alberta that few anglers have ever set foot in. What they found, was an over abundance of healthy Bull trout and Grayling. During our time, we tried to put a new spin on fly fishing for Bull Trout. […]
Detailed instructions for tying an Isonychia Nymph.
A fly fishing trip that took myself and three of my friends to some of Idaho’s best trout waters. Watch as we embark on a 3 day adventure into the Box Canyon of the Henrys Fork and then finish our trip with two days of fishing on Henrys Lake. We arrived to a blizzard and […]
My wife and I were fishing with friend/guide Dean Whaanga in New Zealand when a combination of bad weather and good timing resulted in a fish giving us the experience of a lifetime. I crawled on my stomach with my camera to the waters edge, hit record, and watched what was one of the coolest […]
After a very busy Christmas season that depleted my inventory I am excited to announce that all of my popular styles of fly boxes are back in stock. As always, you can save up to 40% on every box as well as a $5 discount for first time customers. Click Here to Shop Now
Ryleeâ€™s LiLâ€™ Helper is an easy tie midge/larva pattern that has had great success on the White River and Taneycomo. Straight forward and durable pattern, no fluff.